NSFW
Notmyaccount11
Forum Expert
I didn't know whose cock I had acquired, but I sucked it good. I enjoyed the helpless little moans and whimpers from my unknown boy.
I heard similar things from the others, as well as increasingly sloppy sounds as more and more spit got involved with the various blowjobs.
The boys rotated every so often. Anywhere from thirty seconds to a minute, it seemed. Logically, I knew by the third cock in my mouth that one of them had been Ford, and I had indeed had my brother in my pussy and mouth now. For the sake of the game, though, I told myself I didn't truly know who I was sucking on at any given moment.
I was so stupidly wet already. This mystery blowjob thing was working for me. And yes, part of that was the incestuous stakes involved, but just at a basic level it was hot and slutty not knowing whose cock was in my mouth at any point.
Luna was first to take the game further. I mostly noticed as quickly as I did because I currently had no cock in front of me and had cast my gaze around at the other girls. Luna was quick and quiet about slipping her legs under the sheet in front of her, and I was pretty sure neither River or Alyssa realized right away, but whichever guy was currently facing her certainly noticed.
I rubbed my pussy as Luna made a small whimper and her whole body got dragged a little farther away, then shook as she got thrust into. One of the boys was not wasting any time fucking her.
It could be my brother fucking Luna right in front of me. Could even be hers. I didn't know, and I kind of didn't want to know. It was hotter that way.
Luna caught me looking, and just gave me a shy but horny smile. She grinned even wider when I made up my mind and slipped my legs under the sheet too. As soon as the boys rotated again, I had that same cock that had just been in Luna now in my pussy.
Pretty soon Alyssa was copying Luna and I, and all three of us were getting fucked, never quite knowing who was in us. Well, Alyssa could probably recognize her boyfriend, and vice versa. But otherwise I didn't know who was in me, and the boys wouldn't know for sure which pussy they were currently inside either.
I came from getting fucked like that; semi-anonymously, on a rotating handful of cocks. I had my eyes closed, trying to restrain any noises I made, and was surprised to find River crawling up to me when I opened my eyes again.
She leaned down to whisper to me, keeping her words just for us.
"Enjoying yourself?" she asked.
I nodded. "Yeah. Didn't think you'd pass this up though."
River shrugged. "Still kind of sore from last night. And... I kind of want to make sure my sister's having a good time."
"How thoughtful of you," I whispered. "But why do I feel like you're up to something more?"
"Who me?" she asked almost innocently.
"Yeah you."
"Well... maybe you're right."
She waited until Ford was fucking me. Somehow I knew she would, whatever it was she was planning. Like I knew my sister's mind or something.
River threw back the sheet, revealing the familial indiscretion. Not that it stopped Ford or me from fucking. He felt way too good inside me, and fucking my brother was still one of the very hottest things I'd ever done. One of the few I could say I'd beaten River to as well.
"Anyone else want in on this?" River asked casually.
I shrieked in feigned shock and very real delight as Ryan walked over and Ford lay back so I had to ride him.
"This is not very sisterly of you," I told River as she helped Ryan lube and penetrate my ass.
"All depends on what you value, I suppose," River said. "I want the best for you."
Kai stuck his cock in my mouth, and I was fully stuffed in each hole. This was what River wanted for me. And honestly, it was pretty amazing of her. I would never have done it on my own, but with her by my side it felt very manageable. It was certainly a memory I'd treasure forever, whether I ever wanted to do anything like again or not.
The girls were very all very supportive of me. Alyssa held my hair back while Kai fucked my face, and Luna played with my tits, giggling as her brother used my mouth right next to her. River rubbed my back and murmured supportive words to me.
Luckily the boys didn't last too long before cumming in me. I wasn't used to getting fucked like this and wasn't sure how long it would really stay fun for. I did, however, fully enjoy feeling myself take loads of cum in each hole in fairly rapid succession.
I was knocked out of the fun for a bit, too happy and sedate to want to try jumping back onto anyone.
I got to watch Alyssa enthusiastically take both Kai and Ford at the same time though, and Luna makeout with River while getting pounded by Ryan. Luna eventually got her brother inside her and got creampied, as I knew she would sooner or later.
River mostly stayed out of getting actually fucked, and was more of an instigator than anything. It made a sort of sense. As much as she loved being the centre of attention, I also vividly recalled that first time she'd tied Kai up and let anyone who wanted play with him. She didn't need to be right in the middle of things to enjoy herself. Plus she kept saying she was too sore for the poundings she wanted, and I halfway believed that.
Luna eventually crawled over to me and cuddled up. She kissed me, and I found I liked it enough that I held her in for lots more kisses and sucking on her lip.
"Want to go out some time?" she asked me.
I giggled. "You're asking right now?"
"Yeah," she said. "I like you. Spending last night together was fun. This was fun. I'd like to see you more."
"I just finished swallowing your brother's cum," I pointed out.
She shrugged. "I've got some more you could lick out of me if you want."
I covered my face with my hands and tried to muffle my own little scandalized squeals of delight. "Ok, let's try a date."
"Really?"
"Yeah. I think we might work out pretty well, in our own special way."
****
Kai
****
River and I had the firm distinction these days of holding by far the most popular parties of anyone in our increasingly extended friend group. So many of my conversations now involved someone subtly asking when the next event would be.
Luckily for our friends, River and I loved hosting these things, so they rarely had to wait all too long.
"It doesn't strictly have to be one of us tied up every time," I pointed out to River while setting up for our current party.
River shrugged and made sure my arms were tied comfortably but securely above my head, attached to some hooks she'd had one of our friends place on the ceiling.
"But I do so love to watch you get played with," she said.
"Well yeah, same," I said. "Might be nice to be able to play together sometimes is all."
"What are you talking about?" River asked casually. "We had a threeway with your sister just last week. If that's not playing together, I don't know what is."
"Oh yeah," I said. "That's a good point."
"What about his sister?" Luna asked, strolling in with exquisite timing. She held hands with Brooke as they both entered, the two of them having become quite the couple lately.
"Just talking about fucking you last week," River said conversationally. "Kai was pouting that we never do things together."
"Not what I said," I protested.
"You fucked them without me, huh?" Brooke accused Luna.
Luna blushed. "You had that late meeting. I told you, didn't I?"
"You didn't," Brooke said, kissing her lightly. "But River kept me in the loop. Sent me update pics all evening, actually. It was rather frustrating when I was supposed to be focused on other things."
"Sorry," Luna said.
"That's ok," Brooke said. "I'm still going to have River tie you up for the night though."
Luna squeaked in surprise. "What? Me? No."
"Yes," Brooke said calmly.
Luna looked at me, then sheepishly back at her girlfriend. "You sure?"
"I am."
Luna kissed Brooke tenderly. "You're the best."
"I know."
I watched my sister get tied up to another hook. There was something pretty hot about her restraint, even though both of us remained fully clothed. For now.
"You're going to get fucked a lot," I warned Luna. "Like a lot."
She grinned at me. "I know."
River and Brooke happily chatted like they were having some regular sisterly quality time together, while they in fact were tying Luna and I up and blindfolding us, getting us ready to be used.
"They're kind of the best," Luna whispered to me, edging as close to me as she could with the little bit of slack in her bondage. "I get why you like River so much."
"Took you this long?" I asked, amused.
"Well, no. That time she had all her friends suck you off and made you think I might have participated," Luna said. "That's when I knew she was the one for you."
I couldn't help laughing. "That's when you knew?"
"Yeah," she said.
I stopped giggling and thought really hard about it. "Actually... you might be right. I should probably give serious thought to marrying her at some point."
"I can hear you two, you know," River taunted, though she sounded rather pleased.
I shrugged. It wasn't like I minded if she knew.
"So you never actually did anything that first party?" I asked Luna.
"Nah," she said. "Disappointed?"
"A little," I said. "It was fun when I wasn't quite sure."
"You've cummed in me plenty since then," Luna giggled.
"True."
"You're still disappointed?"
"Kinda, yeah."
Luna made an understanding noise. "Tell you what, I'll do something sneaky to you every now and then and refuse to admit to it later."
"I knew you were my favourite sister for a reason," I said.
She snorted and gave me a light kick. I grinned, then perked up as I heard some guests arriving.
Luna and I being as prominent as we were, it wasn't long before we were both getting felt up. The hands and fingers came as a surprise, touching over or under my shirt, across my neck or hair, down my pants.
Luna was getting it as bad or worse judging by the cute noises she made. There was something terribly hot about imagining what might be happening to her, only a foot or two away from me yet remaining unknown.
My pants were pulled down and removed, making my erection very obvious to the whole room. More and more people felt me up, and some clever soul started taking scissors to my shirt. Luna's gasps and the sounds of cutting suggested that she was getting divested of her clothing one way or another as well.
I sighed happily as my cock started getting played with and occasionally sucked a bit. People were starting off slowly, pretty much as expected. Everyone just getting some feels in, or some nibbles and licks here and there.
The only thing I wasn't expecting so much at first was how many fingers would be trying to slide up my butt. Someone--River, no doubt--supplied lube so it was fairly easy and fun, but it made me suspicious of intentions.
I had my suspicious confirmed while I had a wet, eager mouth working my cock. I felt something larger poke my butt, and then there was the tip of a strapon penetrating me, filling me up. Tits pressed to my back as an unknown woman gave a happy sigh and started rocking her hips, fucking me while I was helpless.
"Anyone fucking your ass yet?" I asked Luna.
She moaned. "Working on it. Mostly getting in my pussy so far. Are you...."
"Getting pegged," I confirmed. "River didn't warn me."
"Wouldn't have been much fun that way," River said languidly.
She was probably lounging and watching me get defiled every which way. Probably holding a half-empty wine glass and giving me that cat-like evil smile of hers. God I loved her.
I gasped as my ass was filled with liquid, and I realized that the sex toys involved tonight were going to include fake-cum being shot inside me. It made sense. River would enjoy seeing me get as sloppy as she had last time.
Mouths and hands kept swapping on my dick. Sometimes a girl would sneak her pussy onto me for a bit. From the sounds I heard, it often involved stepping onto something as a boost to make up the height difference, and quite honestly the angle wasn't amazing. But it was good, challenging fun anyway, and I got to eventually sample what I assumed were most of the pussies in the room.
Getting ass-fucked was less frequent, but still pretty regular. Mostly it was one or more strapons getting passed around and stuffed in me over and over, often with large fake cum-load added. Sometimes it was definitely real cocks taking my ass for a ride, and I was very curious who they belonged to, but it was more fun keeping the suspense of not knowing. Plus no one was likely to tell me anyway, lest they face my girlfriend's displeasure.
River was watching all of it, I was sure. Every little thing that our friends wanted to do to me. The thought made me burn even warmer than the bodies rubbing on or in me, or the increasing levels of various fluids accumulating about my person.
A sweaty, naked girl pressed against me from the front, and it took me a moment to realize it was my sister. She clung to me and mewled as she got pounded, then just panted softly as she presumably got finished in again.
"You doing ok?" I whispered.
"Haha, yeah," Luna said. "Of course. You worried about me, bro?"
"Not really. Just checking," I said. "How come you got untied?"
"I don't know. Just special I guess."
It wouldn't have surprised me if someone--most likely one or both of our girlfriends--decided that it was hot watching us get used while pressed needily up against each other. I blindly located my sister's mouth with mine and felt her moan into my kiss.
As if we hadn't already been naked, vulnerable, and helpless enough, we now had to contend with the heat between us, and the constant feel of her tits and my cock trapped against each other, rubbing and poking with every new movement.
I could tell when Luna was feeling particularly desperate and horny from the way she hungrily kissed me. Likewise when she had a cum, she was docile and clingy for a while after.
Someone eventually took pity on me too, and untied my aching arms. I was guided to lie down in the middle of the floor with Luna stretched out on top of me. Some sneaky, helpful hands slipped my cock inside my sister where it just kind of cozily remained.
I felt Luna get fucked some more and knew it had to be in her ass any time she rocked against me. She was so horny and kept grinding on me when she wasn't otherwise getting fucked.
Our free mouths got used plenty still. Dicks and pussies got offered to either or both of us, and occasionally someone would slide in between such that I could suck their clit while Luna ate their ass, or vice versa.
"Keep rocking on me," I begged Luna eventually. "Keep going. I need it."
"Hehe, really?" she giggled. "You need to cum that bad?"
"Yeah."
"In me?"
"Hopefully."
Luna delightedly kept moving her hips. It didn't take much. I was pretty far gone already. I came deep in my sister's wet, messy pussy, releasing so much need and buildup, and nearly knocking me out with pleasure and happy feelings.
Luna and I clung to each other tightly after that, and pretty much gave up on helping anyone else cum. Not that it stopped them. Luna's butt still got used a few more times, but mostly anyone who wanted still came over and came or squirted over the both of us, still using us the cum dumps we were for the evening.
I lost track of time and may have even drifted off a few times, just Luna and I cuddling on the floor in our own slutty way. My blindfold was eventually pulled off and I found River and Brooke the only ones left with us, trying unsuccessfully to pry Luna off of me.
"Let go," Brooke laughed.
"No!" Luna protested petulantly.
"I want a turn on your brother," Brooke insisted. "I haven't used him all night."
Luna slowly relented. "Yeah, ok. That seems fair."
"Good girl," Brooke said, petting Luna and getting her gently curled up next to me.
River watched in amusement and took over petting Luna while her sister climbed on my dick and rode me for a while. I hadn't been in Brooke yet tonight, at least I was pretty sure I hadn't. She seemed pretty pent up and eagerly made herself cum on my cock. She didn't stop riding me until she got me to cum up inside her too.
Brooke only took a moment to enjoy her success before switching over to sitting on Luna's face and making her lick my creampie back out. My sister squealed and play-fought about it, but ultimately wasn't shy about licking out my cum from her girlfriend.
"Such a good girl," Brooke praised adoringly.
River, amused and horny, moved between my legs and licked and sucked on my soft cock until it rose again. She cleaned me of any lingering traces of her sister before straddling me and sitting on my cock. She was in no particular hurry, and just kind of let her hips and pussy grind on me in a slow and luxurious manner.
It felt kind of ridiculous to experience a full body warmth just then as my love for River suffused me. In the aftermath of extreme sluttiness, still an absolute mess inside and out, watching our sisters do some very naughty cum-play right next to us, I felt the intensity of my connection to my girlfriend, and how much we cared for each other.
"I love you," I said.
River flicked her eyes back to me, having been checking out Luna trying to get her whole tongue inside Brooke.
"Of course you do, silly boy," River said. She ran her fingernails up my tummy and chest. "You're a good boy. I love you too. So much."
I smiled at her; soft, innocent, and guileless. "Want to get married?"
River froze. So did Brooke and Luna. I could sense all their attention swiveling rapidly toward me.
"Really?" River asked. "You want to propose now of all times?"
"Yeah," I said. "It feels right."
Luna started giggling uncontrollably, which set Brooke off, and the two of them collapsed together.
"You're not expecting us to be... shall we say... more properly monogamous, are you?" River asked carefully.
"Fuck no," I said. "You kidding?"
"Just checking," she said.
"Nah, I just... I don't want this to end. You and me and... whoever or whatever else. You know?"
River nodded and smiled, biting her lip rather fetchingly. "You don't have a ring, do you?"
"Not at the moment," I said.
"We better start looking then," she said.
"Yeah," I agreed, feeling the blooming coziness in my heart as River leaned down to kiss me. "That seems like a good idea."
****
It felt like no amount of showering, scrubbing, bathing, or any type of cleansing was ever going to get me properly clean again. I still did my best, as tired as I was. I had some intermittent assistance, but River's excitement had caught up with her, and she kept darting out of the room to loudly share more planning and scheming with Brooke. The two of them apparently moving straight to planning the wedding.
"Really did that one to yourself, huh bro?" Luna remarked as she daintily joined me in the bathtub. "Didn't figure River for being so excitable about marriage, quite honestly."
"Me either," I sighed, enjoying feeling Luna's slippery, naked body finding room with mine in the tub. I wasn't horny even a little, but the company still felt nice. River had been in the midst of helping me do a final sweep of my body with a wash cloth before she'd distracted herself again.
"Regret it?" Luna asked.
I smiled, fully content with my life. "Not even a shred. I'm gonna wife that girl."
"Hehe, yeah you are." Luna paused thoughtfully. "Is that gonna make it weird if Brooke and I are still seeing each other?"
I looked at my sister, nakedly sharing my bath with me after having been tied up and gangbanged together.
"Seriously?" I asked.
"Ha, you're right. Who am I kidding. I don't give a shit." Luna raised an imaginary glass. "To us."
I heard similar things from the others, as well as increasingly sloppy sounds as more and more spit got involved with the various blowjobs.
The boys rotated every so often. Anywhere from thirty seconds to a minute, it seemed. Logically, I knew by the third cock in my mouth that one of them had been Ford, and I had indeed had my brother in my pussy and mouth now. For the sake of the game, though, I told myself I didn't truly know who I was sucking on at any given moment.
I was so stupidly wet already. This mystery blowjob thing was working for me. And yes, part of that was the incestuous stakes involved, but just at a basic level it was hot and slutty not knowing whose cock was in my mouth at any point.
Luna was first to take the game further. I mostly noticed as quickly as I did because I currently had no cock in front of me and had cast my gaze around at the other girls. Luna was quick and quiet about slipping her legs under the sheet in front of her, and I was pretty sure neither River or Alyssa realized right away, but whichever guy was currently facing her certainly noticed.
I rubbed my pussy as Luna made a small whimper and her whole body got dragged a little farther away, then shook as she got thrust into. One of the boys was not wasting any time fucking her.
It could be my brother fucking Luna right in front of me. Could even be hers. I didn't know, and I kind of didn't want to know. It was hotter that way.
Luna caught me looking, and just gave me a shy but horny smile. She grinned even wider when I made up my mind and slipped my legs under the sheet too. As soon as the boys rotated again, I had that same cock that had just been in Luna now in my pussy.
Pretty soon Alyssa was copying Luna and I, and all three of us were getting fucked, never quite knowing who was in us. Well, Alyssa could probably recognize her boyfriend, and vice versa. But otherwise I didn't know who was in me, and the boys wouldn't know for sure which pussy they were currently inside either.
I came from getting fucked like that; semi-anonymously, on a rotating handful of cocks. I had my eyes closed, trying to restrain any noises I made, and was surprised to find River crawling up to me when I opened my eyes again.
She leaned down to whisper to me, keeping her words just for us.
"Enjoying yourself?" she asked.
I nodded. "Yeah. Didn't think you'd pass this up though."
River shrugged. "Still kind of sore from last night. And... I kind of want to make sure my sister's having a good time."
"How thoughtful of you," I whispered. "But why do I feel like you're up to something more?"
"Who me?" she asked almost innocently.
"Yeah you."
"Well... maybe you're right."
She waited until Ford was fucking me. Somehow I knew she would, whatever it was she was planning. Like I knew my sister's mind or something.
River threw back the sheet, revealing the familial indiscretion. Not that it stopped Ford or me from fucking. He felt way too good inside me, and fucking my brother was still one of the very hottest things I'd ever done. One of the few I could say I'd beaten River to as well.
"Anyone else want in on this?" River asked casually.
I shrieked in feigned shock and very real delight as Ryan walked over and Ford lay back so I had to ride him.
"This is not very sisterly of you," I told River as she helped Ryan lube and penetrate my ass.
"All depends on what you value, I suppose," River said. "I want the best for you."
Kai stuck his cock in my mouth, and I was fully stuffed in each hole. This was what River wanted for me. And honestly, it was pretty amazing of her. I would never have done it on my own, but with her by my side it felt very manageable. It was certainly a memory I'd treasure forever, whether I ever wanted to do anything like again or not.
The girls were very all very supportive of me. Alyssa held my hair back while Kai fucked my face, and Luna played with my tits, giggling as her brother used my mouth right next to her. River rubbed my back and murmured supportive words to me.
Luckily the boys didn't last too long before cumming in me. I wasn't used to getting fucked like this and wasn't sure how long it would really stay fun for. I did, however, fully enjoy feeling myself take loads of cum in each hole in fairly rapid succession.
I was knocked out of the fun for a bit, too happy and sedate to want to try jumping back onto anyone.
I got to watch Alyssa enthusiastically take both Kai and Ford at the same time though, and Luna makeout with River while getting pounded by Ryan. Luna eventually got her brother inside her and got creampied, as I knew she would sooner or later.
River mostly stayed out of getting actually fucked, and was more of an instigator than anything. It made a sort of sense. As much as she loved being the centre of attention, I also vividly recalled that first time she'd tied Kai up and let anyone who wanted play with him. She didn't need to be right in the middle of things to enjoy herself. Plus she kept saying she was too sore for the poundings she wanted, and I halfway believed that.
Luna eventually crawled over to me and cuddled up. She kissed me, and I found I liked it enough that I held her in for lots more kisses and sucking on her lip.
"Want to go out some time?" she asked me.
I giggled. "You're asking right now?"
"Yeah," she said. "I like you. Spending last night together was fun. This was fun. I'd like to see you more."
"I just finished swallowing your brother's cum," I pointed out.
She shrugged. "I've got some more you could lick out of me if you want."
I covered my face with my hands and tried to muffle my own little scandalized squeals of delight. "Ok, let's try a date."
"Really?"
"Yeah. I think we might work out pretty well, in our own special way."
****
Kai
****
River and I had the firm distinction these days of holding by far the most popular parties of anyone in our increasingly extended friend group. So many of my conversations now involved someone subtly asking when the next event would be.
Luckily for our friends, River and I loved hosting these things, so they rarely had to wait all too long.
"It doesn't strictly have to be one of us tied up every time," I pointed out to River while setting up for our current party.
River shrugged and made sure my arms were tied comfortably but securely above my head, attached to some hooks she'd had one of our friends place on the ceiling.
"But I do so love to watch you get played with," she said.
"Well yeah, same," I said. "Might be nice to be able to play together sometimes is all."
"What are you talking about?" River asked casually. "We had a threeway with your sister just last week. If that's not playing together, I don't know what is."
"Oh yeah," I said. "That's a good point."
"What about his sister?" Luna asked, strolling in with exquisite timing. She held hands with Brooke as they both entered, the two of them having become quite the couple lately.
"Just talking about fucking you last week," River said conversationally. "Kai was pouting that we never do things together."
"Not what I said," I protested.
"You fucked them without me, huh?" Brooke accused Luna.
Luna blushed. "You had that late meeting. I told you, didn't I?"
"You didn't," Brooke said, kissing her lightly. "But River kept me in the loop. Sent me update pics all evening, actually. It was rather frustrating when I was supposed to be focused on other things."
"Sorry," Luna said.
"That's ok," Brooke said. "I'm still going to have River tie you up for the night though."
Luna squeaked in surprise. "What? Me? No."
"Yes," Brooke said calmly.
Luna looked at me, then sheepishly back at her girlfriend. "You sure?"
"I am."
Luna kissed Brooke tenderly. "You're the best."
"I know."
I watched my sister get tied up to another hook. There was something pretty hot about her restraint, even though both of us remained fully clothed. For now.
"You're going to get fucked a lot," I warned Luna. "Like a lot."
She grinned at me. "I know."
River and Brooke happily chatted like they were having some regular sisterly quality time together, while they in fact were tying Luna and I up and blindfolding us, getting us ready to be used.
"They're kind of the best," Luna whispered to me, edging as close to me as she could with the little bit of slack in her bondage. "I get why you like River so much."
"Took you this long?" I asked, amused.
"Well, no. That time she had all her friends suck you off and made you think I might have participated," Luna said. "That's when I knew she was the one for you."
I couldn't help laughing. "That's when you knew?"
"Yeah," she said.
I stopped giggling and thought really hard about it. "Actually... you might be right. I should probably give serious thought to marrying her at some point."
"I can hear you two, you know," River taunted, though she sounded rather pleased.
I shrugged. It wasn't like I minded if she knew.
"So you never actually did anything that first party?" I asked Luna.
"Nah," she said. "Disappointed?"
"A little," I said. "It was fun when I wasn't quite sure."
"You've cummed in me plenty since then," Luna giggled.
"True."
"You're still disappointed?"
"Kinda, yeah."
Luna made an understanding noise. "Tell you what, I'll do something sneaky to you every now and then and refuse to admit to it later."
"I knew you were my favourite sister for a reason," I said.
She snorted and gave me a light kick. I grinned, then perked up as I heard some guests arriving.
Luna and I being as prominent as we were, it wasn't long before we were both getting felt up. The hands and fingers came as a surprise, touching over or under my shirt, across my neck or hair, down my pants.
Luna was getting it as bad or worse judging by the cute noises she made. There was something terribly hot about imagining what might be happening to her, only a foot or two away from me yet remaining unknown.
My pants were pulled down and removed, making my erection very obvious to the whole room. More and more people felt me up, and some clever soul started taking scissors to my shirt. Luna's gasps and the sounds of cutting suggested that she was getting divested of her clothing one way or another as well.
I sighed happily as my cock started getting played with and occasionally sucked a bit. People were starting off slowly, pretty much as expected. Everyone just getting some feels in, or some nibbles and licks here and there.
The only thing I wasn't expecting so much at first was how many fingers would be trying to slide up my butt. Someone--River, no doubt--supplied lube so it was fairly easy and fun, but it made me suspicious of intentions.
I had my suspicious confirmed while I had a wet, eager mouth working my cock. I felt something larger poke my butt, and then there was the tip of a strapon penetrating me, filling me up. Tits pressed to my back as an unknown woman gave a happy sigh and started rocking her hips, fucking me while I was helpless.
"Anyone fucking your ass yet?" I asked Luna.
She moaned. "Working on it. Mostly getting in my pussy so far. Are you...."
"Getting pegged," I confirmed. "River didn't warn me."
"Wouldn't have been much fun that way," River said languidly.
She was probably lounging and watching me get defiled every which way. Probably holding a half-empty wine glass and giving me that cat-like evil smile of hers. God I loved her.
I gasped as my ass was filled with liquid, and I realized that the sex toys involved tonight were going to include fake-cum being shot inside me. It made sense. River would enjoy seeing me get as sloppy as she had last time.
Mouths and hands kept swapping on my dick. Sometimes a girl would sneak her pussy onto me for a bit. From the sounds I heard, it often involved stepping onto something as a boost to make up the height difference, and quite honestly the angle wasn't amazing. But it was good, challenging fun anyway, and I got to eventually sample what I assumed were most of the pussies in the room.
Getting ass-fucked was less frequent, but still pretty regular. Mostly it was one or more strapons getting passed around and stuffed in me over and over, often with large fake cum-load added. Sometimes it was definitely real cocks taking my ass for a ride, and I was very curious who they belonged to, but it was more fun keeping the suspense of not knowing. Plus no one was likely to tell me anyway, lest they face my girlfriend's displeasure.
River was watching all of it, I was sure. Every little thing that our friends wanted to do to me. The thought made me burn even warmer than the bodies rubbing on or in me, or the increasing levels of various fluids accumulating about my person.
A sweaty, naked girl pressed against me from the front, and it took me a moment to realize it was my sister. She clung to me and mewled as she got pounded, then just panted softly as she presumably got finished in again.
"You doing ok?" I whispered.
"Haha, yeah," Luna said. "Of course. You worried about me, bro?"
"Not really. Just checking," I said. "How come you got untied?"
"I don't know. Just special I guess."
It wouldn't have surprised me if someone--most likely one or both of our girlfriends--decided that it was hot watching us get used while pressed needily up against each other. I blindly located my sister's mouth with mine and felt her moan into my kiss.
As if we hadn't already been naked, vulnerable, and helpless enough, we now had to contend with the heat between us, and the constant feel of her tits and my cock trapped against each other, rubbing and poking with every new movement.
I could tell when Luna was feeling particularly desperate and horny from the way she hungrily kissed me. Likewise when she had a cum, she was docile and clingy for a while after.
Someone eventually took pity on me too, and untied my aching arms. I was guided to lie down in the middle of the floor with Luna stretched out on top of me. Some sneaky, helpful hands slipped my cock inside my sister where it just kind of cozily remained.
I felt Luna get fucked some more and knew it had to be in her ass any time she rocked against me. She was so horny and kept grinding on me when she wasn't otherwise getting fucked.
Our free mouths got used plenty still. Dicks and pussies got offered to either or both of us, and occasionally someone would slide in between such that I could suck their clit while Luna ate their ass, or vice versa.
"Keep rocking on me," I begged Luna eventually. "Keep going. I need it."
"Hehe, really?" she giggled. "You need to cum that bad?"
"Yeah."
"In me?"
"Hopefully."
Luna delightedly kept moving her hips. It didn't take much. I was pretty far gone already. I came deep in my sister's wet, messy pussy, releasing so much need and buildup, and nearly knocking me out with pleasure and happy feelings.
Luna and I clung to each other tightly after that, and pretty much gave up on helping anyone else cum. Not that it stopped them. Luna's butt still got used a few more times, but mostly anyone who wanted still came over and came or squirted over the both of us, still using us the cum dumps we were for the evening.
I lost track of time and may have even drifted off a few times, just Luna and I cuddling on the floor in our own slutty way. My blindfold was eventually pulled off and I found River and Brooke the only ones left with us, trying unsuccessfully to pry Luna off of me.
"Let go," Brooke laughed.
"No!" Luna protested petulantly.
"I want a turn on your brother," Brooke insisted. "I haven't used him all night."
Luna slowly relented. "Yeah, ok. That seems fair."
"Good girl," Brooke said, petting Luna and getting her gently curled up next to me.
River watched in amusement and took over petting Luna while her sister climbed on my dick and rode me for a while. I hadn't been in Brooke yet tonight, at least I was pretty sure I hadn't. She seemed pretty pent up and eagerly made herself cum on my cock. She didn't stop riding me until she got me to cum up inside her too.
Brooke only took a moment to enjoy her success before switching over to sitting on Luna's face and making her lick my creampie back out. My sister squealed and play-fought about it, but ultimately wasn't shy about licking out my cum from her girlfriend.
"Such a good girl," Brooke praised adoringly.
River, amused and horny, moved between my legs and licked and sucked on my soft cock until it rose again. She cleaned me of any lingering traces of her sister before straddling me and sitting on my cock. She was in no particular hurry, and just kind of let her hips and pussy grind on me in a slow and luxurious manner.
It felt kind of ridiculous to experience a full body warmth just then as my love for River suffused me. In the aftermath of extreme sluttiness, still an absolute mess inside and out, watching our sisters do some very naughty cum-play right next to us, I felt the intensity of my connection to my girlfriend, and how much we cared for each other.
"I love you," I said.
River flicked her eyes back to me, having been checking out Luna trying to get her whole tongue inside Brooke.
"Of course you do, silly boy," River said. She ran her fingernails up my tummy and chest. "You're a good boy. I love you too. So much."
I smiled at her; soft, innocent, and guileless. "Want to get married?"
River froze. So did Brooke and Luna. I could sense all their attention swiveling rapidly toward me.
"Really?" River asked. "You want to propose now of all times?"
"Yeah," I said. "It feels right."
Luna started giggling uncontrollably, which set Brooke off, and the two of them collapsed together.
"You're not expecting us to be... shall we say... more properly monogamous, are you?" River asked carefully.
"Fuck no," I said. "You kidding?"
"Just checking," she said.
"Nah, I just... I don't want this to end. You and me and... whoever or whatever else. You know?"
River nodded and smiled, biting her lip rather fetchingly. "You don't have a ring, do you?"
"Not at the moment," I said.
"We better start looking then," she said.
"Yeah," I agreed, feeling the blooming coziness in my heart as River leaned down to kiss me. "That seems like a good idea."
****
It felt like no amount of showering, scrubbing, bathing, or any type of cleansing was ever going to get me properly clean again. I still did my best, as tired as I was. I had some intermittent assistance, but River's excitement had caught up with her, and she kept darting out of the room to loudly share more planning and scheming with Brooke. The two of them apparently moving straight to planning the wedding.
"Really did that one to yourself, huh bro?" Luna remarked as she daintily joined me in the bathtub. "Didn't figure River for being so excitable about marriage, quite honestly."
"Me either," I sighed, enjoying feeling Luna's slippery, naked body finding room with mine in the tub. I wasn't horny even a little, but the company still felt nice. River had been in the midst of helping me do a final sweep of my body with a wash cloth before she'd distracted herself again.
"Regret it?" Luna asked.
I smiled, fully content with my life. "Not even a shred. I'm gonna wife that girl."
"Hehe, yeah you are." Luna paused thoughtfully. "Is that gonna make it weird if Brooke and I are still seeing each other?"
I looked at my sister, nakedly sharing my bath with me after having been tied up and gangbanged together.
"Seriously?" I asked.
"Ha, you're right. Who am I kidding. I don't give a shit." Luna raised an imaginary glass. "To us."
