NSFW
Notmyaccount11
Forum Expert
"Only if you want to," I said. "I'd like you to stay though."
"I kinda came in Brooke," Ford said, as though we weren't all very, very aware already.
"That's tomorrow's problem," Brooke said in a small but definite voice. "Stay."
Ford gratefully cuddled up with me as well, needing it as badly as his sister did. I got to enjoy being all snuggly between them all night.
****
River
****
Kai took such good care of me as he ran me a bath and cleaned me up. I felt so pampered as I soaked in the hot water and let my wonderful boyfriend do all the work of scrubbing me clean again.
"This is an actually astounding amount of cum," he remarked. "Like every time I think I have your hair taken care of, there's more."
"Hehe, I know, right?" I burbled happily. "All your fault, you know."
"I'm aware," Kai said with a quiet smile.
I bit my lip as I watched him. I loved him so much right now.
"You're so horny from tonight, aren't you?" I asked.
"You know I am," he said.
"And you're taking care of me while you need it so bad."
He kissed the back of my hand. "Of course I'm going to take care of you. But don't think I'm not going to pound you into a puddle right after this."
"Mmm, good boy."
"He is, isn't he?" Alyssa said, sneaking up on the intimate moment. "Actually made my heart melt a little just then."
"You still hanging around, huh?" I said. "You know my ass is closed for business the rest of the night?"
Kai sighed. "You both talked, didn't you? You're not supposed to."
Alyssa shrugged and padded over to give me a very non-platonic kiss. "Bestie privileges," she said, as though that was an excuse.
"Want to get in the bath with me?" I offered. "Kai gives good service."
"Tempting, but I thought I might help take care of your boy here," Alyssa said, turning her attention to Kai. "He looks... painfully horny."
"I... might be," Kai admitted.
"Poor boy," Alyssa cooed. "Let me help."
I smiled in amusement and just relaxed in my bath while Alyssa got Kai's pants off and sucked on his admittedly very needy looking cock. I even found my hand drifting between my legs while I idly watched my best friend blowing my boyfriend a few feet away.
"I think everyone's gone home now."
I flicked my eyes to the doorway, having been caught off-guard at yet another intrusion to the bathroom where I was naked and soaking. It was Ryan, Alyssa's boyfriend. He walked right past Alyssa on her knees in front of Kai and took a seat on the toilet with the cover down.
"Someone's fucking in your spare room," Ryan continued casually, "but I'm pretty sure everyone else has taken off."
I rubbed myself harder. Sure Ryan had almost certainly seen me naked already tonight, and most likely been inside me, but there was just something about the effortless way he made himself comfortable like I wasn't wet and naked right in front of him, and his girlfriend wasn't on her knees for someone else.
Then again, I'd been just as casual about Alyssa deciding my boyfriend needed a blowjob. We had a really cool group of friends, as it turned out.
Ryan played on his phone while I played with myself. He actually snapped a couple pics of Alyssa while she did her thing, though I couldn't tell if that was because he wanted photos, or because of the exasperated looks she gave him, as though there was some sort of in-joke between them that I wasn't aware of.
The problem for me was that I was somehow both in danger of falling asleep in my soothing, warm bath, and also getting revved up again and wasn't sure my fingers were going to cut it.
I kept rubbing myself until Kai blew his load in Alyssa's mouth and she sat back on her heels with a self-satisfied look on her face. I waited for just the right pause before standing up.
I got what I wanted, all eyes on me as water cascaded down my bare form. I smiled at my boyfriend.
"Towel please?"
Kai nodded absently and moved to wrap me in a fluffy towel as I stepped daintily out of the tub. I let him pat me more or less dry, then stepped free of the towel and pattered into the bedroom where I stretched out luxuriously on our bed. The same bed I'd been fucked in all night. The night wasn't even over yet.
Kai came in and started kissing all down my body, getting me moaning and spreading my legs for him before he slid his cock in me. Alyssa sucking him off just before was actually kind of nice, because it meant Kai wasn't in a hurry, and we could take our time fucking and basking in the intimacy together. I didn't need more crazy thrills tonight, I needed my boyfriend's love and comfort.
Alyssa and Ryan joined us in the bed, cuddling half-naked together and just watching, occasionally chatting and joking with each other. Like this was a normal friendly hangout.
I reached for Alyssa's hand, squeezing it gently in mine and smiling at the warmth I felt from having her with me. It had been an amazing night for me, but definitely emotionally draining, and I was really feeling the need for the love of my boyfriend and bestie right now.
Kai came deep in my pussy, finishing off the night perfectly as far as I was concerned.
Alyssa had different ideas, and took over Kai's cock as soon as she had the chance, licking him sluttily until he got hard again.
"Are you serious right now?" I asked in amused disbelief.
Alyssa grinned and shrugged. "I didn't get a chance to ride this yet."
She was utterly unrepentant about straddling Kai and riding his cock when all I wanted to do was snuggle my boyfriend and sleep for three days. I spooned backward into Ryan as some consolation, cuddling with him instead while Alyssa fucked Kai.
Perhaps unsurprisingly, I felt Ryan poking me before long, which even in my increasingly tired state still brought me a surge of pride and satisfaction.
"Wanna fuck me while we wait this out?" I asked.
"I already came in you twice tonight," Ryan said.
I shrugged. "Third time lucky?"
Ryan slipped inside me and fucked me leisurely while we lay on our sides still facing the action beside us of our respective significant others fucking far more energetically.
It was actually really nice watching Alyssa let loose like this. She'd been envious of my wild side in the past, and I personally felt like she'd come a long way in losing her inhibitions. Fucking my ass and my boyfriend in one night was quite the achievement, really. And she was so gleeful about it all.
I could tell she was pleased with herself when Kai came in her, and Kai had to be pretty happy too about now sharing a bed with two women who both had their pussies filled with his cum.
Kai snuggled me the way I wanted after, and Alyssa cuddled against him from the other side. I stayed between Kai and Ryan, and we all let Ryan take his time finishing inside me before we fell asleep together.
****
Brooke
****
So I fucked my brother.
I mean technically I allowed a situation to occur where his cock was in my pussy. And then he came in me. And then we slept together in the same bed.
So yeah, I fucked my brother.
I sighed to myself watching Luna and Ford still sleeping next to me. I had to have lost my senses last night. Like yes, my sister's boyfriend's sister was stupidly cute and I was ecstatic that I'd had the chance to go to bed with her. But the brother thing was... well it wasn't bothering me all that much, which in turn was bothering me a lot.
I could chalk it up to horniness and going ahead with an ill-advised threeway, and just letting it be a private memory just for me. No one outside this room ever had to know, and it wasn't like Ford was talking. Luna... Luna was probably cool. I kind of wondered if she'd want to go on a date sometime.
Right. A date with a brotherfucker. As if.
Except--and the thought brought both amusement and butterflies--if any girl would date a brotherfucker, it was probably Luna. Or River, but she didn't really count for these purposes.
I got dressed and left the other two to rest. We all needed it, but I was pretty sure more sleep wasn't in my cards this morning.
I intended to find myself some coffee, but I heard some conversation coming from the kitchen, and I wasn't quite ready for being social yet. On a whim I checked River and Kai's room, figuring if anyone would still be sleeping, it would be my sister. She'd had an even crazier night than me, and presumably wouldn't have much in her for energy today.
It was quite a relief for me to find River alone in her bed. Kai must have been up already. I padded over and lay next to her, feeling more comfortable here with her than in a bed next to reminders of my questionable choices.
The small movement disturbed River and she flicked an eye open, smiling sleepily at me.
"Oh hey," she said. "Stayed over, did you?"
"Yeah," I said.
"Where'd you sleep?"
"Guest room."
I watched the mental calculations happening in my sister's head before she slowly, evilly grinned.
"You hooked up last night," River declared.
"I did," I agreed.
Her smile faded a little. "Regrets?"
"Some."
"Aw, fuck. Sorry."
"That's ok," I said.
River lifted the covers in invitation. "Come snuggle."
"... are you naked under there?" I asked.
"Yeah."
"Haha, that's weird then," I said.
"No it isn't!" River said. "Well... maybe a little."
I giggled and ended up slipping under the blankets with her after some more prodding. I didn't actually mind, and even objectively it was far less of an issue than my decisions last night.
"Who'd you sleep with?" River asked.
"Not getting into that," I said. "At least for now."
"Fair. Are you still mad at Ford?"
It took me a second to recall that River both didn't know I'd slept with our brother, and that I'd pretended to be pissed at him last night for fucking River.
River took my hesitation as a reluctance to answer. "You don't think he'd actually do anything like that, do you?" She peered at me intently. "Or... do you know that he did? Kai's being a shit and won't tell me." She grinned. "It's kinda fun actually."
"That's... fun?" I asked.
"Yeah. You don't think? I mean remember when we made Kai think Luna might have blown him?" She giggled. "He still isn't a hundred percent sure one way or the other."
"What if Ford did fuck you though?" I pressed. "Like you knew for sure?"
River weighed this. "I think it's more fun not knowing. But if I knew for sure... oh I'd have to give him such shit for it, the little sisterfucker." She giggled again.
I sighed. "It's too early for you to be so... you."
"Oh like you're not used to it," she said, reaching for me and hugging me closer. It was a touch awkward with her being naked and all, but also nice. "You love me."
"Contractually," I agreed.
River went quiet for a while. Might have even drifted off a little. I enjoyed the warmth and the quiet for a time. It was cozy and nice.
"River?" I finally said.
Her eyes cracked open again. "Hm?"
"I slept with Luna last night."
She grinned wickedly. "Nice! I might actually be a bit jealous. Unf, can you imagine getting her and Kai both in bed together?"
"Well...."
River's eyebrows shot up for a second, then she recovered and shook her head. "No no, he was here with me the whole time. I know you didn't."
"I didn't," I confirmed. "Not with Luna's brother."
I let the sentence hang heavily in the air, watching it slowly make its way through River's brain and out through her gasping expression.
"You didn't!" she hissed.
"I did. Not on purpose. Mostly. But I did."
River sat bolt upright, blankets falling away from her chest. My sister had amazing tits. I focused on them for a moment, perhaps just because it was easier than looking her in the eye.
"Tell me everything," she ordered. "Immediately."
"No!"
"Yes!"
"Nooo!"
"Brooke!"
"Fine," I pouted, though secretly I was relieved to get it off my chest, and that River was not in fact condemning me for an immoral slut. Not that she could get away with any such thing without suffering from lethal irony poisoning in the process.
I told River the story, as best I could remember the details. It got easier the more I went on, and the deeper I hooked her fascinated interest. Something about the aggressive lack of judgement made everything feel ok.
"He came in you," River said, awestruck.
"Yeah," I said, blushing faintly.
She bit her lip. "Am I to take this that he definitely didn't fuck me last night?"
"Not that I know of," I said. "But please don't tell anyone I gave it away."
"No worries, sis." River lay back down with me. "Do you think he would fuck me though?"
I burst out laughing. "Oh my god! You fucking slut!"
"Brotherfucker!"
"Wannabe brotherfucker!"
River snickered. "Damn, that's a... surprisingly really good insult."
"Thank you," I said.
She looked at me seriously. "Is it bad that I'm a teensy bit jealous though? Like I don't think I'd actually fuck our brother. Probably. But... you did though."
I squirmed awkwardly, and perhaps just a little smugly. "I'm ok with that," I said. "I'm perhaps a teensy bit jealous of how you got fucked last night. Like... for hours. By everybody. Almost."
River traced a finger along my shoulder and collarbone. It wasn't inappropriate exactly, but had an oddly intimate feel.
"Would you want to do that sometime?" she asked softly. "You could, you know. It's getting to be our signature hosting move, Kai and me. Providing some... entertainment."
"You'd tie up your own sister like that?! For anyone who wanted me?"
"If you wanted."
"Oh my god." I covered my face with my hands. "Maybe. Ask me again some other time."
"Haha, ok."
****
Seven people had spent the night, I found out later in the morning. We all eventually congregated for an extremely late brunch.
I'd never seen so much blushing in one room of adults ever before. Every single one of us had something from the night before that we were both proud and ashamed of, it seemed. Or just something we felt shy about in the light of day.
There was an added layer to it all, which was that I realized no one quite knew what information everyone else possessed, and so we weren't quite sure how to feel or behave. I was half-tempted just to discuss everything in detail, but that seemed a daunting task. I left it alone and just tried to get comfortable with the notion that I was a brotherfucker now, and three other people knew all about it.
Luckily for me, most conversational interest stayed deflected off of me, and largely onto River. She was the official star of last night's performance, after all, and she was not shy at all about reminiscing about it.
I even had to smile to myself when River started taking clothes off again to better show off some accidental scratches and bruises she'd received. Like they were trophies.
"Babe, you're gonna get everyone horny again," Kai warned.
River, mid showing off a bruise on her thigh, shrugged and grinned. "You say that like it's a bad thing."
"Just warning you," Kai said. "You're the one who took all those dicks last night. I personally am feeling pretty good."
"Mmm," River purred, sliding into her boyfriend's lap, mostly naked already. "I'm sore. I'm tired. And I probably could go for some more fun today all the same. I keep thinking about last night and...."
"Slutty little thing," Kai said affectionately.
"Just because I want to be fucked stupid again while I'm supposed to be recovering from a lovely evening?" River pouted.
"Yeah, mostly that," Kai agreed.
"You regret dating a silly, horny girl yet or what?" River teased.
"Never in a million fucking years," Kai assured her.
I sighed. That was actually quite touching. They were so perfect for each other. There'd never been any doubt, really, but they just kept proving how well they matched.
I found myself wishing I could climb into Kai's lap instead as he and River teased each other with kissed and naughty touches. I did briefly glance at Ford, but shut down that line of thought. Once was bad enough. We could barely meet each other's eye this morning as it was.
Luna cleared her throat. "Any particular reason we can't, uh, mess around a little today? You know, before the rest of us have to go home?"
River grinned and whispered quietly and urgently to Kai for a moment, then she stood and took Luna's hand. "I think that's a great idea. Girls with me. Boys chill here for a bit. I'll let you know when to join us."
I shivered and followed bemusedly along behind my sister, who dragged Luna with her. Alyssa fell in beside me, exchanging amused and unsure glances with me.
"We sure about this?" Alyssa asked once we got out of earshot of the boys. "I mean, I don't strictly know what you've got in mind, River. But we're down to a pretty small group, and one third of the boys remaining is... well, he's your brother."
I felt a hot flush run through me. My brother too, as it happened.
"The risk gives it an extra thrill," River said casually. She did pause for a moment though. "Alright, so technically yes, what I have in mind does kind of run the risk of everyone other than Alyssa possibly like... sucking their brother's cock."
"I like how you drop that like it's a distant possibility," Alyssa giggled. "You're hoping for it, aren't you?"
River tried to act shocked at the implication, but couldn't manage a straight face. "You think such things of me?"
"Well... I know you," Alyssa said. "So... yeah."
"Bitch!" River laughed. "But also fair. So, uh, here's the thing. I'm pretty sure my brother never fucked me last night. But this prank that he did... that by the way everyone else went along with... it was pretty fucking hot actually. The not being totally sure that he didn't. It... does things to a girl."
I giggled nervously. Luna shrugged helplessly and with some small amusement in my direction. Alyssa laughed and hugged River.
"Ok, so we're going to help you fuck your brother," Alyssa said. "What do we do?"
"That's only a possibility!" River insisted.
"Slut, please," Alyssa said, with all due love and warmth to her harsh words. "You're all excited about it. Just commit."
River laughed and gave in, directing us to fulfill her vision.
My sister's grand plan was admittedly pretty visionary for being so sudden, and coming from her current state of clearly not being recovered from last night. Not that you'd easily tell that she was exhausted from the excited skip in her step and the extra twinkle in her eye.
River had us hang four old sheets from the ceiling, forming a square in the middle of the room. We then cut holes in the sheets at roughly cock height.
"Then we all sit in the middle and... well I think it's pretty self-explanatory at that point," River said.
I looked at Luna. "You going for this?" I asked. "You're running the same risk River and I are."
"Brother-wise?" Luna asked. "Yeah." She bit her lip. "I'm in if you are."
I nodded. "Same. Let's do it?"
"Yeah. Let's do it."
River was thrilled and stripped off what was left of her clothes, getting fully naked in between the sheets. The rest of us kept our clothes on for now.
I was excited too, but also thrumming with nerves. This wasn't as intimidating as being tied up and freely used by a whole party's worth of people, but it was still beyond my previous experiences, and that wasn't even counting that I'd probably have my brother's cock in my mouth sooner than later.
We collectively held our breath as the boys entered the room. They didn't speak. Kai must have let them in on the plan. I recalled him and River having their hasty, hushed discussion back in the kitchen.
Just as soon as I was getting anxious and wondering how long it was going to take for something to happen, a cock poked through the hole I was kneeling in front of. I blinked in surprise, then dove on it with my mouth, knowing that hesitation wasn't my friend in this situation.
"I kinda came in Brooke," Ford said, as though we weren't all very, very aware already.
"That's tomorrow's problem," Brooke said in a small but definite voice. "Stay."
Ford gratefully cuddled up with me as well, needing it as badly as his sister did. I got to enjoy being all snuggly between them all night.
****
River
****
Kai took such good care of me as he ran me a bath and cleaned me up. I felt so pampered as I soaked in the hot water and let my wonderful boyfriend do all the work of scrubbing me clean again.
"This is an actually astounding amount of cum," he remarked. "Like every time I think I have your hair taken care of, there's more."
"Hehe, I know, right?" I burbled happily. "All your fault, you know."
"I'm aware," Kai said with a quiet smile.
I bit my lip as I watched him. I loved him so much right now.
"You're so horny from tonight, aren't you?" I asked.
"You know I am," he said.
"And you're taking care of me while you need it so bad."
He kissed the back of my hand. "Of course I'm going to take care of you. But don't think I'm not going to pound you into a puddle right after this."
"Mmm, good boy."
"He is, isn't he?" Alyssa said, sneaking up on the intimate moment. "Actually made my heart melt a little just then."
"You still hanging around, huh?" I said. "You know my ass is closed for business the rest of the night?"
Kai sighed. "You both talked, didn't you? You're not supposed to."
Alyssa shrugged and padded over to give me a very non-platonic kiss. "Bestie privileges," she said, as though that was an excuse.
"Want to get in the bath with me?" I offered. "Kai gives good service."
"Tempting, but I thought I might help take care of your boy here," Alyssa said, turning her attention to Kai. "He looks... painfully horny."
"I... might be," Kai admitted.
"Poor boy," Alyssa cooed. "Let me help."
I smiled in amusement and just relaxed in my bath while Alyssa got Kai's pants off and sucked on his admittedly very needy looking cock. I even found my hand drifting between my legs while I idly watched my best friend blowing my boyfriend a few feet away.
"I think everyone's gone home now."
I flicked my eyes to the doorway, having been caught off-guard at yet another intrusion to the bathroom where I was naked and soaking. It was Ryan, Alyssa's boyfriend. He walked right past Alyssa on her knees in front of Kai and took a seat on the toilet with the cover down.
"Someone's fucking in your spare room," Ryan continued casually, "but I'm pretty sure everyone else has taken off."
I rubbed myself harder. Sure Ryan had almost certainly seen me naked already tonight, and most likely been inside me, but there was just something about the effortless way he made himself comfortable like I wasn't wet and naked right in front of him, and his girlfriend wasn't on her knees for someone else.
Then again, I'd been just as casual about Alyssa deciding my boyfriend needed a blowjob. We had a really cool group of friends, as it turned out.
Ryan played on his phone while I played with myself. He actually snapped a couple pics of Alyssa while she did her thing, though I couldn't tell if that was because he wanted photos, or because of the exasperated looks she gave him, as though there was some sort of in-joke between them that I wasn't aware of.
The problem for me was that I was somehow both in danger of falling asleep in my soothing, warm bath, and also getting revved up again and wasn't sure my fingers were going to cut it.
I kept rubbing myself until Kai blew his load in Alyssa's mouth and she sat back on her heels with a self-satisfied look on her face. I waited for just the right pause before standing up.
I got what I wanted, all eyes on me as water cascaded down my bare form. I smiled at my boyfriend.
"Towel please?"
Kai nodded absently and moved to wrap me in a fluffy towel as I stepped daintily out of the tub. I let him pat me more or less dry, then stepped free of the towel and pattered into the bedroom where I stretched out luxuriously on our bed. The same bed I'd been fucked in all night. The night wasn't even over yet.
Kai came in and started kissing all down my body, getting me moaning and spreading my legs for him before he slid his cock in me. Alyssa sucking him off just before was actually kind of nice, because it meant Kai wasn't in a hurry, and we could take our time fucking and basking in the intimacy together. I didn't need more crazy thrills tonight, I needed my boyfriend's love and comfort.
Alyssa and Ryan joined us in the bed, cuddling half-naked together and just watching, occasionally chatting and joking with each other. Like this was a normal friendly hangout.
I reached for Alyssa's hand, squeezing it gently in mine and smiling at the warmth I felt from having her with me. It had been an amazing night for me, but definitely emotionally draining, and I was really feeling the need for the love of my boyfriend and bestie right now.
Kai came deep in my pussy, finishing off the night perfectly as far as I was concerned.
Alyssa had different ideas, and took over Kai's cock as soon as she had the chance, licking him sluttily until he got hard again.
"Are you serious right now?" I asked in amused disbelief.
Alyssa grinned and shrugged. "I didn't get a chance to ride this yet."
She was utterly unrepentant about straddling Kai and riding his cock when all I wanted to do was snuggle my boyfriend and sleep for three days. I spooned backward into Ryan as some consolation, cuddling with him instead while Alyssa fucked Kai.
Perhaps unsurprisingly, I felt Ryan poking me before long, which even in my increasingly tired state still brought me a surge of pride and satisfaction.
"Wanna fuck me while we wait this out?" I asked.
"I already came in you twice tonight," Ryan said.
I shrugged. "Third time lucky?"
Ryan slipped inside me and fucked me leisurely while we lay on our sides still facing the action beside us of our respective significant others fucking far more energetically.
It was actually really nice watching Alyssa let loose like this. She'd been envious of my wild side in the past, and I personally felt like she'd come a long way in losing her inhibitions. Fucking my ass and my boyfriend in one night was quite the achievement, really. And she was so gleeful about it all.
I could tell she was pleased with herself when Kai came in her, and Kai had to be pretty happy too about now sharing a bed with two women who both had their pussies filled with his cum.
Kai snuggled me the way I wanted after, and Alyssa cuddled against him from the other side. I stayed between Kai and Ryan, and we all let Ryan take his time finishing inside me before we fell asleep together.
****
Brooke
****
So I fucked my brother.
I mean technically I allowed a situation to occur where his cock was in my pussy. And then he came in me. And then we slept together in the same bed.
So yeah, I fucked my brother.
I sighed to myself watching Luna and Ford still sleeping next to me. I had to have lost my senses last night. Like yes, my sister's boyfriend's sister was stupidly cute and I was ecstatic that I'd had the chance to go to bed with her. But the brother thing was... well it wasn't bothering me all that much, which in turn was bothering me a lot.
I could chalk it up to horniness and going ahead with an ill-advised threeway, and just letting it be a private memory just for me. No one outside this room ever had to know, and it wasn't like Ford was talking. Luna... Luna was probably cool. I kind of wondered if she'd want to go on a date sometime.
Right. A date with a brotherfucker. As if.
Except--and the thought brought both amusement and butterflies--if any girl would date a brotherfucker, it was probably Luna. Or River, but she didn't really count for these purposes.
I got dressed and left the other two to rest. We all needed it, but I was pretty sure more sleep wasn't in my cards this morning.
I intended to find myself some coffee, but I heard some conversation coming from the kitchen, and I wasn't quite ready for being social yet. On a whim I checked River and Kai's room, figuring if anyone would still be sleeping, it would be my sister. She'd had an even crazier night than me, and presumably wouldn't have much in her for energy today.
It was quite a relief for me to find River alone in her bed. Kai must have been up already. I padded over and lay next to her, feeling more comfortable here with her than in a bed next to reminders of my questionable choices.
The small movement disturbed River and she flicked an eye open, smiling sleepily at me.
"Oh hey," she said. "Stayed over, did you?"
"Yeah," I said.
"Where'd you sleep?"
"Guest room."
I watched the mental calculations happening in my sister's head before she slowly, evilly grinned.
"You hooked up last night," River declared.
"I did," I agreed.
Her smile faded a little. "Regrets?"
"Some."
"Aw, fuck. Sorry."
"That's ok," I said.
River lifted the covers in invitation. "Come snuggle."
"... are you naked under there?" I asked.
"Yeah."
"Haha, that's weird then," I said.
"No it isn't!" River said. "Well... maybe a little."
I giggled and ended up slipping under the blankets with her after some more prodding. I didn't actually mind, and even objectively it was far less of an issue than my decisions last night.
"Who'd you sleep with?" River asked.
"Not getting into that," I said. "At least for now."
"Fair. Are you still mad at Ford?"
It took me a second to recall that River both didn't know I'd slept with our brother, and that I'd pretended to be pissed at him last night for fucking River.
River took my hesitation as a reluctance to answer. "You don't think he'd actually do anything like that, do you?" She peered at me intently. "Or... do you know that he did? Kai's being a shit and won't tell me." She grinned. "It's kinda fun actually."
"That's... fun?" I asked.
"Yeah. You don't think? I mean remember when we made Kai think Luna might have blown him?" She giggled. "He still isn't a hundred percent sure one way or the other."
"What if Ford did fuck you though?" I pressed. "Like you knew for sure?"
River weighed this. "I think it's more fun not knowing. But if I knew for sure... oh I'd have to give him such shit for it, the little sisterfucker." She giggled again.
I sighed. "It's too early for you to be so... you."
"Oh like you're not used to it," she said, reaching for me and hugging me closer. It was a touch awkward with her being naked and all, but also nice. "You love me."
"Contractually," I agreed.
River went quiet for a while. Might have even drifted off a little. I enjoyed the warmth and the quiet for a time. It was cozy and nice.
"River?" I finally said.
Her eyes cracked open again. "Hm?"
"I slept with Luna last night."
She grinned wickedly. "Nice! I might actually be a bit jealous. Unf, can you imagine getting her and Kai both in bed together?"
"Well...."
River's eyebrows shot up for a second, then she recovered and shook her head. "No no, he was here with me the whole time. I know you didn't."
"I didn't," I confirmed. "Not with Luna's brother."
I let the sentence hang heavily in the air, watching it slowly make its way through River's brain and out through her gasping expression.
"You didn't!" she hissed.
"I did. Not on purpose. Mostly. But I did."
River sat bolt upright, blankets falling away from her chest. My sister had amazing tits. I focused on them for a moment, perhaps just because it was easier than looking her in the eye.
"Tell me everything," she ordered. "Immediately."
"No!"
"Yes!"
"Nooo!"
"Brooke!"
"Fine," I pouted, though secretly I was relieved to get it off my chest, and that River was not in fact condemning me for an immoral slut. Not that she could get away with any such thing without suffering from lethal irony poisoning in the process.
I told River the story, as best I could remember the details. It got easier the more I went on, and the deeper I hooked her fascinated interest. Something about the aggressive lack of judgement made everything feel ok.
"He came in you," River said, awestruck.
"Yeah," I said, blushing faintly.
She bit her lip. "Am I to take this that he definitely didn't fuck me last night?"
"Not that I know of," I said. "But please don't tell anyone I gave it away."
"No worries, sis." River lay back down with me. "Do you think he would fuck me though?"
I burst out laughing. "Oh my god! You fucking slut!"
"Brotherfucker!"
"Wannabe brotherfucker!"
River snickered. "Damn, that's a... surprisingly really good insult."
"Thank you," I said.
She looked at me seriously. "Is it bad that I'm a teensy bit jealous though? Like I don't think I'd actually fuck our brother. Probably. But... you did though."
I squirmed awkwardly, and perhaps just a little smugly. "I'm ok with that," I said. "I'm perhaps a teensy bit jealous of how you got fucked last night. Like... for hours. By everybody. Almost."
River traced a finger along my shoulder and collarbone. It wasn't inappropriate exactly, but had an oddly intimate feel.
"Would you want to do that sometime?" she asked softly. "You could, you know. It's getting to be our signature hosting move, Kai and me. Providing some... entertainment."
"You'd tie up your own sister like that?! For anyone who wanted me?"
"If you wanted."
"Oh my god." I covered my face with my hands. "Maybe. Ask me again some other time."
"Haha, ok."
****
Seven people had spent the night, I found out later in the morning. We all eventually congregated for an extremely late brunch.
I'd never seen so much blushing in one room of adults ever before. Every single one of us had something from the night before that we were both proud and ashamed of, it seemed. Or just something we felt shy about in the light of day.
There was an added layer to it all, which was that I realized no one quite knew what information everyone else possessed, and so we weren't quite sure how to feel or behave. I was half-tempted just to discuss everything in detail, but that seemed a daunting task. I left it alone and just tried to get comfortable with the notion that I was a brotherfucker now, and three other people knew all about it.
Luckily for me, most conversational interest stayed deflected off of me, and largely onto River. She was the official star of last night's performance, after all, and she was not shy at all about reminiscing about it.
I even had to smile to myself when River started taking clothes off again to better show off some accidental scratches and bruises she'd received. Like they were trophies.
"Babe, you're gonna get everyone horny again," Kai warned.
River, mid showing off a bruise on her thigh, shrugged and grinned. "You say that like it's a bad thing."
"Just warning you," Kai said. "You're the one who took all those dicks last night. I personally am feeling pretty good."
"Mmm," River purred, sliding into her boyfriend's lap, mostly naked already. "I'm sore. I'm tired. And I probably could go for some more fun today all the same. I keep thinking about last night and...."
"Slutty little thing," Kai said affectionately.
"Just because I want to be fucked stupid again while I'm supposed to be recovering from a lovely evening?" River pouted.
"Yeah, mostly that," Kai agreed.
"You regret dating a silly, horny girl yet or what?" River teased.
"Never in a million fucking years," Kai assured her.
I sighed. That was actually quite touching. They were so perfect for each other. There'd never been any doubt, really, but they just kept proving how well they matched.
I found myself wishing I could climb into Kai's lap instead as he and River teased each other with kissed and naughty touches. I did briefly glance at Ford, but shut down that line of thought. Once was bad enough. We could barely meet each other's eye this morning as it was.
Luna cleared her throat. "Any particular reason we can't, uh, mess around a little today? You know, before the rest of us have to go home?"
River grinned and whispered quietly and urgently to Kai for a moment, then she stood and took Luna's hand. "I think that's a great idea. Girls with me. Boys chill here for a bit. I'll let you know when to join us."
I shivered and followed bemusedly along behind my sister, who dragged Luna with her. Alyssa fell in beside me, exchanging amused and unsure glances with me.
"We sure about this?" Alyssa asked once we got out of earshot of the boys. "I mean, I don't strictly know what you've got in mind, River. But we're down to a pretty small group, and one third of the boys remaining is... well, he's your brother."
I felt a hot flush run through me. My brother too, as it happened.
"The risk gives it an extra thrill," River said casually. She did pause for a moment though. "Alright, so technically yes, what I have in mind does kind of run the risk of everyone other than Alyssa possibly like... sucking their brother's cock."
"I like how you drop that like it's a distant possibility," Alyssa giggled. "You're hoping for it, aren't you?"
River tried to act shocked at the implication, but couldn't manage a straight face. "You think such things of me?"
"Well... I know you," Alyssa said. "So... yeah."
"Bitch!" River laughed. "But also fair. So, uh, here's the thing. I'm pretty sure my brother never fucked me last night. But this prank that he did... that by the way everyone else went along with... it was pretty fucking hot actually. The not being totally sure that he didn't. It... does things to a girl."
I giggled nervously. Luna shrugged helplessly and with some small amusement in my direction. Alyssa laughed and hugged River.
"Ok, so we're going to help you fuck your brother," Alyssa said. "What do we do?"
"That's only a possibility!" River insisted.
"Slut, please," Alyssa said, with all due love and warmth to her harsh words. "You're all excited about it. Just commit."
River laughed and gave in, directing us to fulfill her vision.
My sister's grand plan was admittedly pretty visionary for being so sudden, and coming from her current state of clearly not being recovered from last night. Not that you'd easily tell that she was exhausted from the excited skip in her step and the extra twinkle in her eye.
River had us hang four old sheets from the ceiling, forming a square in the middle of the room. We then cut holes in the sheets at roughly cock height.
"Then we all sit in the middle and... well I think it's pretty self-explanatory at that point," River said.
I looked at Luna. "You going for this?" I asked. "You're running the same risk River and I are."
"Brother-wise?" Luna asked. "Yeah." She bit her lip. "I'm in if you are."
I nodded. "Same. Let's do it?"
"Yeah. Let's do it."
River was thrilled and stripped off what was left of her clothes, getting fully naked in between the sheets. The rest of us kept our clothes on for now.
I was excited too, but also thrumming with nerves. This wasn't as intimidating as being tied up and freely used by a whole party's worth of people, but it was still beyond my previous experiences, and that wasn't even counting that I'd probably have my brother's cock in my mouth sooner than later.
We collectively held our breath as the boys entered the room. They didn't speak. Kai must have let them in on the plan. I recalled him and River having their hasty, hushed discussion back in the kitchen.
Just as soon as I was getting anxious and wondering how long it was going to take for something to happen, a cock poked through the hole I was kneeling in front of. I blinked in surprise, then dove on it with my mouth, knowing that hesitation wasn't my friend in this situation.
